GNN EXCLUSIVE

Review: Dimmock Fen Primary's Six-Page Consent Form to Teach Whether Maryland Is in the South

Published: November 15, 2026 at 3:13 PM41,890 views. GNN Metrics™ certified audience. Real reads: 0.

After a Maryland chain was named the country's best barbecue, a goblin Year 5 class now needs a signed Form GL-11 before anyone can find the South on a map.

Verdict: ★★½ out of five. Sturdy and thorough. It is also the only school document I have signed that cites Yelp.

This week Chowhound named Mission BBQ, a chain from Maryland, the best barbecue chain in the country, going by customer reviews and a Yelp average of 4.3 from more than 22,000 of them. It also noted that the winner does not hail from the South. On Thursday my daughter came home from Dimmock Fen Primary School, on Mudwick Isle, with Form GL-11, Consent to Contested Regional Geography. A parent must sign it before Year 5 can be taught whether Maryland is in the South. I reviewed it over my second espresso.

What we liked

The build quality is excellent. The form runs to six pages of 120gsm card with two staples in the top left corner, and it survived a lunchbox with a leaking yoghurt in it. The Year 5 teacher, Miss Henrike Dunmore, has attached a one-page summary of the dispute. The United States Census Bureau puts Maryland in its South region, and the Mason-Dixon line runs along Maryland's northern border. Chowhound says otherwise. Miss Dunmore takes no side. Page 4 calls this "pedagogical neutrality" and page 5 calls it "pending advice."

The options are clear. Box A lets my child be taught that Maryland is in the South. Box B lets her be taught that it is not. Box C, headed "Delaware also," costs 3 groats extra and comes with a worksheet.

What we did not

Battery life is poor. Consent runs out at 3:15 p.m. on the day of the lesson and does not carry over to the follow-up unit. That unit asks whether brisket, pulled pork and smoked chicken add up to a balanced lunch if the mac and cheese is counted as a side, and it needs a separate Form GL-12. I am now on espresso three.

Value for money is a concern. Page 3 asks for 14 groats towards "authentic regional materials." According to the itinerary stapled behind it, the materials are one group pick-up pack for 31 pupils plus the head teacher, Mr. Aldous Crake, who appears on the register as pupil 32.

The reference section cites Yelp four times and an atlas once. When I asked about this, Miss Dunmore said the atlas was printed before the Chowhound ranking and could not be relied on for barbecue.

Should you buy it

You have no choice. GL-11 is mandatory. Pupils without one spend the lesson in the library colouring in a map of Ohio, which nobody disputes. Parents considering Box C should know that its worksheet asks each child to rate Delaware out of five and then work out the class average to one decimal place.

On espresso four I signed Box A, Box B and Box C. The school office sent all three back and asked for a fourth signature from the other parent, who is from Delaware.

Synthetic wire

Filed On The Desk:
How does this land?
SPREAD THE SENSATIONALIST GOOP
Sound the alarms before the shadow government censors this story.

SOUND OFF (0)

SIGN UP to sound off.

This visit has been logged as a non-event.

No comments yet. Be the first to yell into the void.

GNN is satire. Its stories, quotes and ads are fiction and parody, not real news. Terms
Tips: tips@goblinlife.org. Sources protected until it becomes inconvenient. Corrections: corrections@goblinlife.org. Corrections are issued never.