A stratigraphic survey of the cork board at Mallowfield Mansions dates the landlord's new 9-florin Notice Board Upkeep Charge to the top layer and his last boiler pledge to the bottom.
Abstract. The cork notice board in the ground-floor lobby of Mallowfield Mansions, a 22-flat goblin residential building on Nettlecombe Road, was excavated by the Mallowfield Mansions Residents' Committee over three evenings in October, after the landlord, Mr. Osric Penhallow of Penhallow Lettings, posted a notice introducing a monthly 9-florin "Notice Board Upkeep Charge." Seven depositional layers were identified, comprising 38 notices and 212 staples, to a total depth of 11 millimetres. The basal layer was found to contain a notice signed by the landlord in March 2019 stating that the boiler "will be seen to this week." The boiler has not been seen to (one member asks that it be recorded that it has been seen, frequently, by everyone, from the stairwell).
Methods
Excavation followed the single-context recording method of Tamsett (2011), adapted from field archaeology for use on cork. Each notice was photographed in situ and its staples counted, then removed with a butter knife from Flat 6, the committee's only staple remover having been lent to the landlord in 2022 and not returned. Layers were distinguished by paper discolouration and by the presence of drawing pins, which were banned by a notice in Layer III and therefore provide a reliable terminus post quem (a minority of the committee held that it was a terminus ante quem, and this disagreement occupied the first 40 minutes of the second evening). Work was conducted between 7:15 and 9:40 p.m. under the lobby bulb, which runs on a 90-second timer and was pressed 97 times.
Results
Measurements are given in Table 1.
| Layer | Approx. date | Depth (mm) | Notices | Staples | Dominant subject |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I (top) | Oct 2026 | 0–1 | 4 | 19 | Upkeep Charge; a bicycle |
| II | 2025–26 | 1–3 | 7 | 41 | Bins |
| III | 2024 | 3–5 | 9 | 52 | Drawing-pin ban; bins |
| IV | 2023 | 5–7 | 6 | 33 | Parcels in hallway |
| V | 2021–22 | 7–9 | 5 | 30 | Staple remover (wanted) |
| VI | 2020 | 9–10 | 4 | 21 | Boiler (follow-up) |
| VII (base) | Mar 2019 | 10–11 | 3 | 16 | Boiler |
| Total | 11 | 38 | 212 |
The mean rate of deposition was calculated as notices per year, with staple density rising toward the surface, consistent with the landlord's written position that the board is "under strain." The boiler is mentioned in 11 of the 38 notices, all of them deeper than 7 millimetres. The Layer VI follow-up, also signed by the landlord, reads in full "Engineer booked." No engineer was recovered from any layer. (Flat 14 reports that a bath currently requires six kettles and that the kettle is the one from Layer IV, "Found in hallway, is this yours.")
Discussion
The principal finding is that the Upkeep Charge is levied on a board whose upkeep, to the full depth measured, has been carried out by tenants. A majority of the committee regards the basal notice as a binding undertaking under the doctrine of the posted promise (Quarrie and Lund, 2017); Mrs. Dorcas Fennimore of Flat 3 regards it as "a sheet of paper" and asked that her objection be minuted twice, which it was, although a second faction maintains that minuting an objection twice constitutes two objections and has asked for a ruling. Mr. Penhallow was contacted by a note left in the letterbox marked "Landlord (Correspondence)," which is also the letterbox of Flat 1. He replied in writing that the excavation had damaged the cork, and that the cost of replacement cork would be added to the Upkeep Charge, which now stands at 11 florins.
Whether the 2019 notice should be re-pinned at the surface, laminated, or forwarded to the Lettings Tribunal was put to a vote at 10:05 p.m. The vote was tied 6–6, Flat 9 having gone upstairs to start boiling a bath. Further discussion was deferred to the next meeting, and the motion to adjourn was not completed, because the lobby light timed out during the seconding.




