
The Directorate of Defence Stationery scored the VerityBand 7 zero out of 40 for arriving opened, then resealed each sample with tape reading "INSPECTED — INTACT."
GRISTLEFORD — All 14 tamper-evident envelope seals submitted by goblin defence contractor Dunmarrow Seal & Fastening Works for a Directorate of Defence Stationery contract arrived at the evaluation panel already opened, after the Directorate's own post room opened each one to confirm it was sealed, this Senior Correspondent for Adhesives and Deterrence can report.
The panel scored the bid 0 out of 40 under criterion 3(b), "Sample integrity on receipt," and awarded the 6,200-unit contract to the only other bidder, which had delivered its samples by hand.
Dunmarrow's product, the VerityBand 7, turns from green to red when broken. All 14 samples were red on arrival Thursday at 9:52 a.m. Each had also been resealed with Directorate tape stamped "INSPECTED — INTACT."
"Our seal did exactly what page 4 of the brochure says it does," said Quilla Ashgrove, Dunmarrow's Director of Government Sales. "Fourteen goblins opened it, and it told the panel 14 times. We consider this the most successful field trial in the company's history."
Morwen Clatchet, Supervisor of the Central Post Room in Building 6, said her staff followed Standing Order 22, which requires every package marked "SEALED" to be opened and checked for a seal.
"The label said sealed. We have to verify that," Clatchet said. "They were sealed. We wrote that on the tape."
This story now belongs to the Mailroom and Siege desk.
Dunmarrow lodged a nine-page objection, Bid Protest DS-0417, on Friday. It was returned unread Monday morning because the envelope was marked "CONFIDENTIAL," which under Standing Order 22 requires the post room to read it first. One post-room clerk has since been fully briefed on Dunmarrow's unit pricing.
Tibalt Wendrake, Deputy Assessor for Envelopes and Closures, said the panel had no discretion. "The criteria say intact on receipt. I have 14 red seals and a note from the post room saying they are intact," he said. "Those cancel out to zero."
The Directorate has bought tamper-evident seals since its 1994 reorganisation, when an internal audit found that 31 percent of its classified envelopes had been licked shut. The winning bidder, Pottlecombe Closures, supplies a plain brown band that does not change colour when opened. Its samples scored 40 out of 40.
Ashgrove said Dunmarrow will resubmit next quarter with each sample sealed inside a second VerityBand 7, so the post room has something to open.




